Let me begin by asking a question. Do you prefer positive feedback more than negative feedback? I know, that's a pretty general question but think about it for a moment. Perhaps we need to know what the words 'positive' and 'negative' mean in this situation.
You've worked hard on your project and you're proud of it but you want to be sure it is solid and something others would want to read. In order to find out this information you round up a few of your trusted peers and send them your work. They, as your beta readers, in turn provide you with feedback. This brings us to the question above. What would you rather hear from your betas - "oh, this is a wonderful book and you should get this published" or "I liked the characters but the pace was a little slow at times"?
As I journey down this road and gain more experience with every turn I'm starting to see that feedback takes many forms but can be placed in three categories. Don't get me wrong, I believe two categories serve a purpose while one is....well, we will get to that. Which of the two is more valuable to the author? Well, in order to answer that question we need to look at the two categories.
Category One: The Feel Good Feedback
I consider this to be positive feedback. We've all seen it and I would guess that many of us have received it. Examples of feedback that would fit in this category would be:
- I loved the way you described each character. They really jumped off the page.
- The settings were so real in my mind.
- I truly enjoyed reading your book.
- Wow, I didn't see that ending coming at all.
Positive feedback, such as the above examples, provide us with a little insight to the story but mostly it helps to build our confidence and can possible answer some questions we may have. For instance, you wonder if your characters are to plain; maybe they seem flat to you. If you were to get feedback stating that your characters jumped off the page than you would have a little reassurance about your writing when it comes to character development.
The feedback for this category is very helpful when it comes to building up the self confidence and the willingness of an author to push the limits and explore more. I believe we tend to restrain our abilities until we either feel that we have grasped the basics or we have confirmation from others that what we are doing is good. When you receive feedback like this be grateful for it; take it for what it’s worth and continue moving forward.
Category Two: That Stings a Little Feedback
This is the category that many would consider negative feedback or constructive criticism. Just like positive feedback, I'm sure we have seen and/or received negative feedback. Examples that would fit in this category are:
- The hook was good but I don't think it was strong enough to carry me through the story.
- The pace was to slow in some scenes and to fast in others.
- I liked character 'A' but character 'B' seemed plain.
- The dialog didn't match the time period.
- The ending was good but I think there were some holes remaining.
Feedback like this can leave us feeling deflated and shaken. Sometimes we can even get angry because we know that at a minimum we need to go through our project and see if the feedback is correct. Granted we could discard all of it and say the manuscript is fine as is but many of us will look into the problem areas. If we agree with the feedback then we frustrated because of the added work we just picked up. This, in essence, is way we call this negative feedback...we don't like it.
There is one thing we need to keep in mind regarding negative feedback; it is a more critical examination of the story when compared to positive feedback. Granted all feedback is based on opinion but we can investigate the points of negative feedback. We should want this type of feedback because, even though we don't like it, it provides us with the most information about our skill and the story we have developed. It helps us identify the areas we need to work on.
Category Three: Bad Feedback
This is the category where we find all the feedback that is just not helpful at all. Yes, unfortunately we do receive feedback that fits perfectly in this category. Some examples are:
- The beginning sucks.
- What's up with that ending?
- Uuuummmm, I didn't get it.
- You haven't quit your day job yet have you?
The majority of the time very general comments or hurtful comments end up in this category. They simply don't provide any substance in which we can work with. It is safe to assume that we will, at some point in time, receive feedback like this. Should this happen don't let it bring you down. Keep going and disregard it; focus on the feedback that helps you.
Which is more helpful?
We know that category three is not the most helpful so it comes down to category one or two. Category one has an important place in the life of an author but I'm not so sure it is the most helpful. Negative feedback, in my opinion, is the most helpful because it provides us with the most to work with and the most insight. The key words to remember is 'constructive criticism;' meaning it is not bad, just pointing out something we may need to work on. If you think about it, negative feedback could very well provide the most positive return.
What kind of feedback have you received? Did it fit one of the categories above?